| ALCS MVP | ||
| 2023 | ADOLIS GARCIA |
TEXAS RANGERS |
| 2022 | JEREMY PENA |
HOUSTON ASTROS |
| 2021 | YORDAN ALVAREZ |
HOUSTON ASTROS |
| 2020 | RANDY AROZARENA |
TAMPA BAY RAYS |
| 2019 | JOSE ALTUVE |
HOUSTON ASTROS |
| 2018 | JACKIE BRADLEY |
BOSTON RED SOX |
| 2017 | JUSTIN VERLANDER |
HOUSTON ASTROS |
| 2016 | ANDREW MILLER |
CLEVELAND INDIANS |
| 2015 | ALCIDES ESCOBAR |
KANSAS CITY ROYALS |
| 2014 | LORENZO CAIN |
KANSAS CITY ROYALS |
| 2013 | KOJI UEHARA |
BOSTON RED SOX |
| 2012 | DELMON YOUNG |
DETROIT TIGERS |
| 2011 | NELSON CRUZ |
TEXAS RANGERS |
| 2010 | JOSH HAMILTON |
TEXAS RANGERS |
| 2009 | C.C. SABATHIA |
NEW YORK YANKEES |
| 2008 | MATT GARZA |
TAMPA BAY RAYS |
| 2007 | JOSH BECKETT |
BOSTON RED SOX |
| 2006 | PLACIDO POLANCO |
DETROIT TIGERS |
| 2005 | PAUL KONERKO |
CHICAGO WHITE SOX |
| 2004 | DAVID ORTIZ |
BOSTON RED SOX |
| 2003 | MARIANO RIVERA |
NEW YORK YANKEES |
| 2002 | ADAM KENNEDY |
ANAHEIM ANGELS |
| 2001 | ANDY PETTITTE |
NEW YORK YANKEES |
| 2000 | DAVID JUSTICE |
NEW YORK YANKEES |
| 1999 | ORLANDO HERNANDEZ |
NEW YORK YANKEES |
| 1998 | DAVID WELLS |
NEW YORK YANKEES |
| 1997 | MARQUIS GRISSOM |
CLEVELAND INDIANS |
| 1996 | BERNIE WILLIAMS |
NEW YORK YANKEES |
| 1995 | OREL HERSHISER |
CLEVELAND INDIANS |
| 1993 | DAVE STEWART |
TORONTO BLUE JAYS |
| 1992 | ROBERTO ALOMAR |
TORONTO BLUE JAYS |
| 1991 | KIRBY PUCKETT |
MINNESOTA TWINS |
| 1990 | DAVE STEWART |
OAKLAND ATHLETICS |
| 1989 | RICKEY HENDERSON |
OAKLAND ATHLETICS |
| 1988 | DENNIS ECKERSLEY |
OAKLAND ATHLETICS |
| 1987 | GARY GAETTI |
MINNESOTA TWINS |
| 1986 | MARTY BARRETT |
BOSTON RED SOX |
| 1985 | GEORGE BRETT |
KANSAS CITY ROYALS |
| 1984 | KIRK GIBSON |
DETROIT TIGERS |
| 1983 | MIKE BODDICKER |
BALTIMORE ORIOLES |
| 1982 | FRED LYNN |
CALIFORNIA ANGELS |
| 1981 | GRAIG NETTLES |
NEW YORK YANKEES |
| 1980 | FRANK WHITE |
KANSAS CITY ROYALS |
